I’d like to acknowledge I reviewed this for StoryLinks.
Brotherband, The Caldera, 7, starts with the annual Maktig contest. Stigâs father, Olaf,
arrives to ask Hal and his Heron brotherband fighters to save a 14-year-old emperor kidnapped by the pirate Myrgos. The action, tension and adventure begin when the Heron brotherband set off on their quest.
However, if you didnât read the blurb, the opening paragraph was a basic fight scene. At the end of the paragraph there was a hint of a contest. But it wasnât until the end of the fight weâre informed itâs the coveted annual Maktig competition. The Maktig or âMighty Oneâ carries great authority and prestige among Skandians. Mentioning it from the onset, would have orientated readers to hang on to every â grip, impact, ram and lock.
Having grown up with Hal, Thorn, Stig and Flanaganâs way with the series, it was unexpected to meet contemporised language and behaviours. Hal, Skirl of the Heron and Thorn, his Battlemaster, had spent years in the Heron brotherband or traversing into The Rangerâs Apprentice series. Thorn would not ââŚmade a little moue (pout) of surprise,â when he found out Hal had been training Stig at night. He may have raised his eyebrow or offered a nod of approval. And neither would Thorn ââŚregard the young warrior with new respectâ given the years sailing together. Also, as they watched a form of ârock, paper, scissorsâ for Ulf and Wulfâs Maktig event â their âsniggeringâ jarred and lingered on the page, far too long.
Some unnecessary words, phrases and sentences dotted throughout has interrupted the readerâs participation. When Olaf talks about Halâs reputation, Hal shrugs it off ââŚuninterested.â However, the following sentence, âIf Olaf had intended to flatter him, it hadnât worked.â The reader would conclude this. Some extraneous words have interrupted character traits e.g.., Olaf nodded âmeeklyâ, âThorn grunted âsarcasticallyâ, Thorn âsmothered a short bark of laughter.â Also, while setting sail, Lydia would not ask Hal about âthe figure muffled in his fur coatâ. She would wait until the skirl was ready.
The tension and action started when ââŚunder the guise of nightâ the Heron passed Erak, the Oberjarl, in Wolfwind. Hal had set sail to get Olaf out â avoiding further Navigatorsâ Guild committee scrutiny, and to save the young emperor. Flanagan allowed us to enjoy
Halâs every thought and strategy when outsmarting the pirate Myrgos and his ramming Vulture.
The end epilogue would please readers with the Heron brotherband sailing towards Araluen, into The Rangerâs Apprentice Series. Flanagan could have doubled the excitement, if Hal mentioned it would delay facing the Oberjarl and the executive committee.
Brotherband, The Caldera, 7, fits neatly into the successful Brotherband series whose world of the Skandian people â trading to survive, supporting allies and fighting evil, evolved into John Flanaganâs incredible series in 2011.




Hello Maria,
I enjoyed The Caldera as well. I agree with you that the first scene of the book was pretty exciting. Have you heard if John Flanagan is going to write a Book 8 for the Brotherband series?
LikeLike
No I haven’t yet. Particularly as he recently brought out another for the Ranger’s Apprentice series. Love how they entwine their characters in some.
LikeLike